Battery health: The number that now sets your EV residuals

By Marcus Berger, CEO, Aviloo

Marcus Berger, CEO, Aviloo

At defleet, the value of a company car has always come down to a few familiar checks: how old it is, how far it has gone and what condition it is in. For an electric car, that misses the part that matters most. The battery is the most valuable component in an EV, and its condition says more about what the car is worth than the odometer does. Battery health is becoming the new mileage.

Our recent EV Battery Study, based on more than 500,000 tests on used EVs across 20 popular models, shows how much it varies. The state of health, the battery’s remaining capacity compared with when it was new, can differ by up to 16.4% between cars of the same model. Two cars from the same fleet order, driven similar distances, can come back with very different batteries and very different values.

The average hides the risk

Headline figures on battery health tend to be reassuring, and on average they are right. The median Tesla Model Y we tested still holds 90% of its original capacity at around 93,000 miles (150,000km). But a fleet does not sell the median car. It sells individual vehicles, and among Model Ys alone we see differences of up to 11.4%. A fleet or leasing company can model the average perfectly and still lose money on the cars at the wrong end of the range.

Will the battery outlast the fleet cycle?

On our data, mostly yes. The batteries we test typically lose capacity gradually, and many are still in good health well beyond the mileage a company car covers in one contract. The 70% often quoted as the end of a battery’s life is a warranty convention, not a physical limit.

If the battery holds up, longer contracts and higher-mileage use become realistic options, and whole-life costs come down. But durability only pays if the next buyer believes in it. In a consumer survey we ran this year across eight markets in Europe and the US, battery uncertainty came out as the biggest barrier to buying a used EV. Respondents rated a reliable battery check as their top priority, yet only 49.3% knew a battery can be tested at all. In the UK, it was 46%. What a buyer cannot verify, they price in as a discount.

Why the figure must be independent

When a car comes off contract, its bodywork and tyres are assessed against an agreed standard, often by an independent inspector. The battery is worth far more than the paintwork, and it deserves the same treatment.

The state of health figure a car reports is an estimate from the manufacturer’s own software, and getting it right is hard even for the people who built the car. A buyer, an auction house or a lender needs a result measured by someone who is not a party to the sale, using one method across all makes.

Fleet and lease returns are now reaching the used market in volume, and that is where most used EV transactions will happen over the next few years. The burden of proof sits with the seller, and fleets have the most to gain from a market that trusts what it is buying.

What fleet decision-makers can do

Start early: test each car independently when it joins the fleet and again during the contract, so you can see which ones are ageing faster than their peers. A certificate at defleet then gives the next buyer a reason to pay for the battery’s real condition rather than their worst fears.

Use the data in decisions on contract length, remarketing channels and the next choice list. And look at the independent battery warranties now on the market. Based on a measured State of Health, they protect the next owner if the battery ages faster than expected after purchase, which gives buyers one more reason to choose an ex-fleet EV.

The evidence so far is good news for fleets. But a residual value is only as strong as the proof behind it, and fleets will only be paid for a healthy battery when the figure comes from someone with nothing to gain from the answer.

Natalie Middleton

Natalie has worked as a fleet journalist for nearly 20 years, previously as assistant editor on the former Company Car magazine before joining Fleet World in 2006. Prior to this, she worked on a range of B2B titles, including Insurance Age and Insurance Day. Natalie edits all the Fleet World websites and newsletters, and loves to hear about any latest industry news - or gossip.